You can’t help but conclude, on acquainting yourself with the established players in the market segment that the new Mini Convertible is entering, that buyers of downsized drop-tops aren’t a very demanding bunch.

There is evidence that people will pay close to £20,000 for cars that are slow, unresponsive and impractical and feel flimsy and imprecise on the road – provided they come with a roof that lets the sunshine in and a must-have badge on their bonnet. 

Matt Saunders Autocar

Matt Saunders

Road test editor
Mini’s drop-top style icon offers substance, integrity and plenty of fun

Against that background, BMW could have got away with ‘phoning one in’ with this car – but to its credit, it hasn’t.

The Mini Convertible feels like a much better-engineered car than it needs to be, one of integrity and attention to detail, improved significantly over the car it replaces.

It opens up the vivacious Mini driving experience to the elements without compromising it. And given that open really does mean open with this car and doesn’t with most of its rivals, that’s no mean feat.

Hence why the Mini Convertible leads the way in our top five beating the Volkswagen Beetle, DS 3, Fiat 500C and Vauxhall Adam Rocks Air in the process.

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week

However, for the facelift we think Mini need to address the gearing by giving it a shorter final drive, make the seats comfier, thicker and softer and to further refine and fettle the steering set-up.

Save money on your car insurance

Compare quotesCompare insurance quotes

Find an Autocar car review

Driven this week